Prefer and Would Rather

by | Jun 10, 2024 | English Grammar in Use

“Prefer” and “would rather” are common expressions used to indicate choices and preferences in English. Although they are similar in meaning, their usage and grammatical structure differ. In this guide, we will explore what these expressions mean, how they are used, when to use them, and provide examples along with a mini quiz to test your understanding.

What's your English level?

Take the test and get your certificate!

Prefer vs would rather

What is “Prefer”?

“Prefer” is a verb used to express a liking for one thing over another. It indicates a general preference and is often followed by a noun or verb.

How is “Prefer” Used?

With Nouns: “Prefer” is followed by a noun to compare two things.

  • Example: “I prefer tea to coffee.”

With Gerunds: “Prefer” is followed by the -ing form of the verb.

  • Example: “She prefers reading to watching TV.”

With Infinitives: “Prefer” can also be followed by the infinitive form of the verb.

  • Example: “They prefer to walk rather than drive.”

What is “Would Rather”?

“Would rather” is used to express a specific preference for one thing over another in a particular situation. It is followed by the base form of the verb.

How is “Would Rather” Used?

Simple Preferences: Used to show preference for one action over another.

  • Example: “I would rather stay home than go out.”

Subject Changes: For another person’s present or future action, use “would rather” followed by the subject and a past-simple verb. For a past action, use a past-perfect clause.

  • Example: “I would rather you stayed home.”

When to Use “Prefer” vs. “Would Rather”

“Prefer”

General Preferences: Use “prefer” to indicate general preferences or habitual likes.

  • Example: “He prefers summer to winter.”

Comparing Two Actions: Use “prefer” with gerunds or infinitives to compare two actions.

  • Example: “I prefer reading books to watching movies.”

“Would Rather”

Specific Situations: Use “would rather” for specific choices in particular situations.

  • Example: “She would rather go to the beach than the mountains.”

Different Subjects: Use “would rather” when expressing a preference involving another person.

  • Example: “I would rather he told the truth.”

Examples of “Prefer” vs. “Would Rather”

  • Prefer: “I prefer chocolate to vanilla.”
    Would Rather: “I would rather eat chocolate than vanilla.”
  • Prefer: “She prefers jogging in the morning.”
    Would Rather: “She would rather jog in the morning than in the evening.”
  • Prefer: “They prefer watching movies at home.”
    Would Rather: “They would rather watch movies at home than go to the cinema.”
  • Prefer: “We prefer to travel by train.”
    Would Rather: “We would rather travel by train than by car.”
  • Prefer: “He prefers playing guitar to playing piano.”
    Would Rather: “He would rather play guitar than play piano.”

Difference Between Prefer and Would Rather

Prefer and would rather can both express a choice. Their grammatical patterns are more reliable guides than a strict “formal versus informal” rule: compare “I prefer to work alone” and “I would rather work alone.” Use to with this infinitive after prefer, but not after would rather.

Grammar Structures with Examples

Here are the most common structures you need to know:

StructureExample
prefer + noun/gerund + toI prefer walking to driving.
prefer + infinitive + rather thanI prefer to walk rather than drive.
would rather + base verb + thanI’d rather walk than drive.
would rather + subject + past verbI’d rather you came earlier.
would rather + have + past participleI’d rather have stayed home than gone out.

If you want to learn more about modal verbs, check our guide on Modal Verbs in English.

Would Prefer or Would Rather?

For a present or future choice, would prefer can express a similar preference to would rather, but it takes a different verb form.

ChoiceWould preferWould rather
My own actionI would prefer to revise tonight.I would rather revise tonight.
A negative choiceI would prefer not to rush.I would rather not rush.
Another person’s actionI would prefer you to send the draft tomorrow.I would rather you sent the draft tomorrow.

Another person’s action in the past

Use a past-perfect clause when a different subject’s action is already in the past: “I would rather you had sent the draft yesterday.” Compare this with “I would rather have sent it yesterday,” where the speaker is the person who would have sent it. Review have + past participle after would rather for the same-subject pattern.

Practical Tips for Learners

Check the verb immediately after the preference expression. Write prefer to revise or prefer revising, but would rather revise. With would prefer, use to revise.

Then identify the person and the time. “I would rather you revised tonight” concerns someone else’s present or future action. “I would rather you had revised yesterday” concerns that person’s past action.

What's your English level?

Take the test and get your certificate!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the main difference between prefer and would rather?

The verb pattern changes: “I prefer to read” and “I would rather read” can express a similar choice. Context determines whether the preference is general or tied to one occasion.

Can I use would prefer instead of would rather?

Often, but adjust the structure: “I would prefer to wait” corresponds to “I would rather wait.” Do not write “I would prefer wait.”

How do I describe another person’s past action?

Use would rather + subject + past perfect: “I would rather they had asked first.” For your own past choice, use would rather have + past participle.

Recommended External Resources

For further reading, check these authoritative English grammar resources:

Key Takeaways

  • Use prefer for general preferences and choices.
  • Use would rather for specific or situational preferences.
  • Remember the grammar rules:
    • prefer + noun/gerund
    • prefer + to + verb
    • would rather + base verb
    • would rather + subject + past verb
  • Practice with both forms to sound fluent in different contexts.

Check the Different Patterns

Choose the correct form: (1) I would prefer ___ online. (to study / study) (2) I would rather ___ online. (to study / study) (3) I would rather you ___ me tomorrow. (called / had called) (4) I would rather you ___ me yesterday. (called / had called)

Answers: 1. To study, after would prefer. 2. Study, without to after would rather. 3. Called, a past form with future meaning. 4. Had called, for the other person’s past action.

Prefer and Would Rather Exercises

Complete the sentences using “prefer” or “would rather” correctly:

  1. I ________ coffee to tea.
  2. She ________ stay at home tonight.
  3. They ________ eating out to cooking at home.
  4. He ________ go for a walk than watch TV.
  5. We ________ swimming to running.
  6. I ________ you didn’t tell anyone about this.
  7. She ________ to work in the morning.
  8. They ________ travel by train than by bus.
  9. He ________ reading books to listening to music.
  10. I ________ you came early tomorrow.

Answers:

  1. prefer
  2. would rather
  3. prefer
  4. would rather
  5. prefer
  6. would rather
  7. prefers
  8. would rather
  9. prefers
  10. would rather

Understanding the difference between “prefer” and “would rather” helps you express choices and preferences more accurately. Use this guide to master these expressions and improve your English communication skills!

Test your English level and get your certificate!

img#pf-header-img { width:40% !important; margin-top:10px !important; margin-bottom:20px; margin-left:0 !important; } #pf-content > div:nth-child(1) > div > div > div.et_pb_module.et_pb_post_content.et_pb_post_content_0_tb_body > div > div > div > div > div > div > div.et_pb_button_module_wrapper.et_pb_button_0_wrapper.et_pb_module > a {background-color:#F2330E; border-radius:50px; padding:10px; padding-left:30px; padding-right:30px; font-weight:bold;color:#fff; margin-bottom:50px !important;text-decoration:none !important;} h1 {font-size: 40px !important; margin-top:15px !important; margin-bottom: !important; padding-bottom:5px !important;}